Showing posts with label psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label psychology. Show all posts

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Yes, I do have my own TV show

Today was the second pre-production meeting for a show with the working title, "BPC Moment." When I was first approached to host this in-house, closed circuit, television program, they wanted to call it "BPC Live"... I guess hoping that it would be "as good as" Saturday Night Live. Given that my feelings on SNL are mixed AND that "Live" can as easily be read with a short "i" as a long one, I suggested the title change. What's wrong with a short "i" in "live"? In this case, BPC is a long-term care psychiatric facility whose average length of stay currently exceeds one year. We don't want patients to think of themselves as living at BPC. We want them oriented on returning to the community; that their time in BPC is only a moment in their life. Hence, the title change.

Yeah, TV production is filled with all sorts of stupid arguments like the above. And, doing a TV show in a psychiatric facility has its own special issues and its own special opportunities. I'll spare you the issues and get you in on the "excitement" of the opportunities.

Since they asked me to host, I have done more than argue a program name change. I also suggested a talk show format and essentially bullied my way into pre-production meetings to act as a producer. Before I got involved, they were imagining a one-hour call in show ala Dr. Phil - with me dispensing pithy bits of earthy wisdom. Here are the zany ideas I countered with:
  • I only want 15 minutes devoted to call-ins. The rest will be guest interviews and featured patient creative works. The last ten minutes of the hour will be given to the units to engage patients in discussion of the show.
  • I want a patient as a co-host.
  • I want a patient as a production technician.
  • In addition to interesting staff, I want successful mental healthcare recipients as guests.
  • I want to feature patient poetry, essays, musical pieces, and performance art.
  • I want patients to submit "fan mail" and suggest future show topics.
All of those ideas were approved.

So far so good.
  • I want 2 cameras, vision mixer with DVE, and a Character Generator.
  • I want 2 wireless mics and a mixing console
  • I want a studio with a host desk and chair, a guest couch, area rug, and wall decorations.
Um...

"It is good to dream, Dr. Reynolds," they say to me. Instead I will have one camera, one microphone, a desk with two chairs, and a fabric backdrop set up in the the corner of the video production room.

Well, that's showbiz!

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Nature and Pharmacy

When some people talk about mental illness, the emphasis has become almost entirely upon biology -- specifically genetics involving neurology and neurochemistry.  They may give a tip of the hat to the world we live in by stating that stressful events are the likely trigger of the expression of genetics with undesirable consequences.  But, if there is a solution to be had, it is almost solely in the manipulation of neurochemistry to address "a chemical imbalance."

These people speak of a chemical imbalance as if it is NOT one of several competing hypotheses to explain mental health issues.  While I have certainly witnessed some medication have miraculous effects on people, it rarely is a total cure.  Moreover, I have witnessed sufficient examples of medication having little to no effect to be confident that the chemical imbalance hypothesis is just that -- a hypothesis.  

So, why do people buy into the chemical imbalance hypothesis more so than the psychological and social hypotheses of mental health problems? If  I were a cynical person I would think that it is simply about money.  That there is more money to be made in pharmacy than there is in self-help books and support groups or even therapy session bills.  That may play its role, but I actually don't believe that to be the reason for the success of the chemical imbalance hypothesis in the fight for the hearts and minds of people.

Certainly one reason may be that biology is viewed as a hard science -- more "true" because it involves things that can be easily touched and measured.  Measurement leads to numbers and attaching numbers to life can be reassuring to people.  Numbers are believed to be a meaningful reference, a touchstone that people can believe tells them something about what is happening and if there is change.  This is of course not exactly true.  There is no true "zero" on these scales and thus they are really arbitrary with no fixed scale.  Thus, the numbers are only relative to other numbers on the exact same scale.  Therefore, the information can not be easily generalized.

Another explanation is the loss of guilt.  If biology is to blame, that means the identified patient is not.  Come on?  Who can choose their biological make-up? Even the parents aren't somehow responsible.  Afterall, they too were born with unchosen genetics and had no way to control what they would pass along and in what combination.  This also means that a person is essentially powerless by themselves to change the situation.  This leads to solutions external to themselves.  While this could result in such a person seeking medication advice from a physician, it seems as likely that they will seek external "solutions" through the use of alcohol and illegal drugs.

The last reason I imagine that the chemical imbalance hypothesis is so appealing is that people want relief from discomfort and they want it quickly.  The idea of "life is pain" to many is just a funny throwaway line from a movie ("Princess Bride").  The chemical imbalance hypothesis is appealing in this manner as it leads to a quick solution.  No need to change your lifestyle or how you view or react to life.  Take this pill and problem solved.  Of course, it rarely if ever works out  that way.

I don't think any one of the above reasons explains the success of the chemical imbalance hypothesis.  It unfortunately is likely a combination of these reasons that keeps some people misinformed, powerless, and dissatisfied with the care they receive.   And, more importantly, not looking to other possible explanations and solutions.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Psychotherapy and third-party payment

Three psychologists and a managed care rep were driving down a steep mountain road when the brakes began to fail.  They bring the car to a stop using the emergency brake.  All four get out and discuss how to deal with the problem.


One psychologist states, "we should get back in the car and drive again.  Do not react to anything the car does or fails to do.  The resulting free action demonstrated by the car will be very informative regarding its pathology and eventually lead to a solution."


"That's ludicrous!" bellows a second psychologist.  "We should get back into the car and drive.  But, every time the car succeeds in braking we should reward it with gasoline."


The third psychologist offers, "I think we should just accept this car for itself.  It should feel supported by us whether it can brake or not."


The managed care rep declares, "well, no matter what any of you do, every 100 yards I'll decide whether we keep driving or jump out of the car."


So, all four get back in the car and resume driving down the road.  One hundred yards later the managed care rep makes them all jump out.  They watch with some sadness as the car goes over a curb and then off of a cliff.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Internet parasites

I had the opportunity to speak to some middle-schoolers regarding sex offenders on the internet.  While preparing for this presentation, I had an insight; there really is not much out there designed with children as the primary audience.  If you browse the internet or even contact the FBI directly, you will find out that what is out there is created for parents.

As a psychologist, I knew this kind of material would be difficult to bring across effectively to children.  So, here is an analogy that parents can use to help their children understand the need for internet safety rules. 

Imagine the internet as a forest.  It is huge and you can find all sorts of things in it: beautiful things and grotesque things; safe things and dangerous things.  If you stay on the paths, you can be led to all sorts of interesting and wonderful things.  Stray from a path and you could get lost or even hurt.

A child should be nodding along up until the getting hurt part.  After all, how could the internet hurt someone?  Ask them, when they are in a forest, how often they think that an animal is watching them?  They will likely guess a low number.  You can say with confidence that, whether they knew it or not, most of the time some animal is watching a person as they go through the forest.  Some of those animals are dangerous. 

You can remind your child that they have never gotten hurt by any animal while in the forest.  Then ask them, why is that?  If they don’t come up with the answers on their own, tell them: because they were with an adult they knew; because they followed basic rules that pretty much assured their safety.  The internet has its own version of dangerous animals. If people don’t follow basic rules for safety, those animals will try to hurt them. 

At this point you will have to decide how much more your child can or should know with regard to exactly how these people can hurt a child.  For most children, I would say that these people try to fool you into thinking they are a friend.  And, once they think they have fooled you, they will try to hurt you. 

Now, with a more understandable image of the internet in place, your child is ready to hear some of the material available to parents with regard to basic internet safety.

There is one other point on this topic.  It regards the term “internet predator.”  This is a key phrase associated with this topic and it is the first time I’ve used it in this commentary.  That is because I really do not like that phrase.

For me, the word “predator” has a cool “danger-mystique” surrounding it.  When I think of the word predator I think of wolves, tigers… you know, cool, beautiful, dangerous animals.  This is not the image I want to associate with sex offenders.  They are dangerous.  Some could be physically engaging but all sex offenders are certainly NOT cool.

So, what other phrase would I suggest?  I believe the word predator is used because we think of sex offenders as “hunting” for their victim like a predator hunts its prey.  In addition, the word predator suggests something that we must be aware of and guard against.  There is another type of animal that we must guard against and hunts for its prey besides predators.

Parasites!  Parasites have a specific prey or host that it hunts.  We must take precautions against parasites or be attacked by them.  Like a predator, a parasite can cause physical harm to its prey.   In addition, unlike a predator, a parasite can cause lasting change in the behavior of its prey!  For those of you who know someone victimized by a sex offender, you know that the physical trauma does heal, but the traumatic stress will change your loved one’s behavior for years afterward.  Finally, where we attempt to respect predators and live alongside them, I believe that most people want to stay as far away from parasites as possible.

So, I propose that we drop the term “internet predator.”  It is not only a horrible allusion to predatory animals but I believe it is also inaccurate in both the image and the idea it conveys about sex offenders on the internet.  Instead, I would encourage the use of the phrase “internet parasite.”  Personally, I think it is not only more accurate, it just feels right.  I would rather associate the idea of an internet sex offender with a tick or a worm than with a tiger or a wolf.

Friday, January 23, 2009

Who supervises the supervisors?

As with most things, we can only be as good as the people we surround ourselves with.  For a psychologist in particular, the most important person in that mix is the supervisor.  Having been trained to provide supervision, I used to think that I was pretty good at it.  Fortunately that delusion was dissolved when one supervisee as much as told me that she had felt like she was floating in an ocean with sharks circling.  What did I do wrong?  Well, probably a lot of things at the time... but, how can I be at least a "good enough" psychologist-supervisor for my next victim... I mean supervisee?  Here are three rules:


First things first, supervision is not therapy.  While I believe it is important for a supervisor to be aware of any particular "buttons" or "issues" the supervisee feels could effect his or her performance, a supervisor should not use "the voice" and try to get the supervisee on the proverbial couch.   I know I had a couple of supervisors who I dreaded talking to because I got the impression they were more interested in my personal damage  than helping me improve my clinical technique.


Second, provide structure.  No matter how advanced your supervisee is, everyone likes to start off being directed as if they were a first year student.  Give articles to read.  Tell the rules of the setting and go over how therapy works -- according to your school of thought.  Really scrutinize technique and give plenty of feedback early on.   More advanced supervisees should quickly tire of your structuring and give you signs that they are ready to go beyond the basics.  I try to pick up on clues before the snoring or blank stares followed by standing up and walking out of supervision 30 minutes early.  Of course, with experience you will be able to rely less on their level of irritation to inform you as to when to back off.


Third, balance the challenge.  Certainly meet the supervisee where they are at from a professional development standpoint as well as an emotional one.  Push too softly and they will feel like the experience is a waste.  Push too hard and you will crush their spirit.


So far, I have been good with point one.  That's it.  For those receiving supervision, give feedback as soon as you realize what is not going well.  These are the basic opening lines that I think supervisees should use (with me anyway):


For problems with Rule 1: "I was wondering if we could spend more time on my conceptualization of this client I am working with?"


For problems with Rule 2: "I am not sure I quite understand how you believe I could be handling this case.  Could you work with me a little on how to develop a treatment plan?"


For problems with Rule 3 - low challenge:  "I think I would like to work with some more challenging cases."


For problems with Rule 3 - excessive challenge: "Wow, I feel like I have a long way to go.  I think I need a lot more supervision on this."


Try these out.  Raise your voice level as need be but, please, no spitting or hitting.  Talk to your supervisor's supervisor if you must.  And, believe me, you might have to.  I know I have had supervisees who used some of the above statements and I do not think I responded well to their hints at a need for improved supervision.  My only defense is that providing supervision is as much a work in progress as developing a therapeutic style. 

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Medical model versus Psychodynamic theory

The word "iatrogenic" is almost exclusively used to mean an adverse effect or complication related to the provision of health care.  The word "iatrogenesis" really refers to both the good or bad effects related to but not the actually intent of the actions of a healer.  So, why is iatrogenesis almost always used to refer to negative effects? I could just say that many who use the term in this manner are control freaks and think anything that happens that they did not will to be is therefore bad.  But, then this would be a short post.  Instead I will focus on how I believe that the emphasis on the negative points to what I believe is the essential difference between the medical/behavioral model and psychodynamic theory.


The medical/behavioral model, in my opinion, operates on the assumption that what is critical in the success of an intervention is not the interventionist, it is the quality of the intervention itself.  A medication will be successful if it is the appropriate medication at the appropriate dose.  A homework assignment will be successful if appropriately presented, conducted, and reviewed.  The only concern for the exact nature of the relationship between a healthcare recipient and a doctor is that it be professional.  Anything that occurs that was not expected from the intervention is interpreted as due to "error" or a "placebo effect."  


Psychodynamic theory, conversely, is very concerned with the nature of the relationship between the psychologist and the client.  The concepts of transference and counter-transference clearly emphasize that it is the therapeutic relationship which is the critical component of healing.  When anything occurs that was not expected from the intervention, it is interpreted as informative about the client's personality, history, and presenting problem.  The unforeseen improvement or insight is considered a boon not a burden.  


Then what should we do with undesired, unforeseen, negative results of intervention?  How should we react to institutionalization -- an iatrogenic effect of long-term care?  I believe psychodynamic theory indicates that we should understand the dynamics of the relationship between the client and the institution.  For example, does a client become institutionalized because at some level the hospital unwittingly promotes that result?  Or could it also be that a battered soul will choose the safety of a cell over the responsibility and dangers inherent in freedom? Such informed analyses could potentially lead to both policy and procedural change that could reduce the incidence of institutionalization.  With the current emphasis on the medical/behavioral model, I am doubtful that such analyses will be performed, let alone operationalized, in the near future.  But, it is a seed that should be planted and nurtured by new, up-and-coming doctors -- psychiatrists as well as psychologists.